1. Who was studied, and are they like the person deciding?

    A result applies most directly to people like the ones in the study. Age, sex, health, risk, and setting all matter. A finding in older adults with heart disease may say little about a healthy 40-year-old.

    Before asking whether a study is right, ask whether it is about someone like you.

  2. What question did the study ask, and what outcome changed?

    Find the exact question and the outcome that moved. Did people live longer, have fewer heart attacks, or feel better? Or did a blood marker move?

    A change in a lab value is called a surrogate outcome. It is not the same as a change in how people live or die, and the two sometimes disagree.

  3. Does the comparison support the conclusion?

    Every study compares one group with another. In a randomized trial, chance decides who gets what, so the groups start out alike.

    In an observational study, people choose for themselves, and the people who choose a habit often differ in many other ways. That difference, called confounding, can make a habit look helpful when it is really a marker of who keeps it.

  4. How large and how certain was the finding?

    Look for the absolute change, not only the relative one. A drug that cuts a risk in half sounds dramatic, but cutting a risk from two in a hundred to one in a hundred helps one person in a hundred.

    Then look at how precise the estimate is. A wide range of plausible results means the study has not settled the question.

  5. What does it add to the existing evidence?

    One study is rarely the last word. Ask how it fits with what was already known. A surprising result from a small study deserves more caution than one that agrees with several large ones.

    When new findings conflict with old ones, the better-designed study usually deserves more weight, not simply the newer one.

  6. What would it change for this person?

    This is the question that matters. Given this person's risk, health, and priorities, would acting on the finding help more than it costs?

    Sometimes the honest answer is to act now. Sometimes it is to wait, watch, and revisit as the evidence or the person changes. That step, from evidence to one decision, is what I call the judgment gap.

Related reading